The scaffolding method is any pedagogically justified sequence of using and not
using technology for trivialization, experimentation, visualization, or
concentration either in the sense of automation or compensation. (Bernhard Kutzler)
In mixed ability teaching CAS is a pedagogical tool
whereby we can keep all students at the same level of conceptual
learning while allowing technology to temporarily take over areas of
algorithmic difficulty. For example, students readily recognize the
meaning of horizontal turning points, i.e., points along a curve where
the gradient function is equal to zero. They may have difficulty
remembering chain, product, or quotient rules and the rules involved in
simplification of algebraic expressions. While individual students can
spend more time working on individual difficulties involving these
procedures either in class or for homework, the entire class can
proceed to interesting problems using Calculus while allowing the
technology to perform the tedious processes involved in finding
derivatives, performing 2nd derivative tests, and simplifying the expressions
they obtain. Very often they cannot satisfactorily answer or interpret
their solutions in light of the problem because of numeracy or
“algebracy” errors.
The same is true for more elementary topics, such
as solving a system of equations in 2 unknowns. The students readily
understand the need to eliminate a variable or solve for one variable
in terms of the other in order to perform a substitution, but often
have difficulties with numeracy or procedures, e.g., they forget to
multiply both sides
of the equations by the chosen number when using elimination. In such
cases it is pedagogically valid to allow the student to use CAS as a
scaffold over such difficulties in order to proceed with the underlying
algebraic structures of this topic, or its applications.
By way of example, we can suppose that a student
still has difficulties with the equivalence transformations in solving
equations but most of the class is ready to proceed with solving
systems of equations. We can allow such students to temporarily use the
“solve” buttons as follows:
Or, if this is a word problem that has successfully
been translated into a mathematical system, we might want to allow
students to solve directly so as to enable them the opportunity to correctly interpret the
solution in light of the original problem.